Library Instruction:
What's a Scholarly Source?!?
|
A well-structured source written by experts and intended for
experts, students, and scholars in the field. |
Defining Scholarly Sources
A scholarly source is one that meets the following criteria:
- Authority
- Are the author or authors identified?
- Do they have scholarly credentials, or credentials within the appropriate field of expertise?
- Structure
- Do the authors cite the works from which they drew inspiration and/or information?
- Do illustrations relay vital information (charts, etc.), rather than simply making the
article or book more attractive?
- Content
- Is the intended audience a group of scholars or a group of people who have expertise in a particular
trade or profession?
- Is the language is specific to the discipline or intended for large audiences?
Don't think of a scholarly source as something that's been stamped SCHOLARLY
SOURCE. Think of it as a resource which is authoritative, which is
structured and presented professionally, and which has content and style appropriate
to a scholarly rather than a popular audience.
Sometimes some of these criteria will be more important than others. For instance, a trade
magazine on the advertising industry with an article on
the marketing of beer to minors may be appropriate for a class in mass
communication or marketing, but inappropriate for a class on the biological
effects of alcohol on underage drinkers. While the publication is intended for people in a particular
trade, and not mainly for scholarly consumption, the information in the magazine can be useful to students
of advertising, rhetoric, and marketing.
Types of Sources
| Primary
Sources |
Primary Sources are original materials which have not been interpreted
or condensed. They represent original observations or documentation of occurrences (such
as interviews, conducting a survey, carrying out a laboratory experiment, letters, diaries,
or journals) and include statistical data, historical
documents, and works of literature and art. |
| Secondary
Sources |
Secondary Sources provide information or analysis of primary sources.
They often take primary source data and modify, select, or arrange the material for
a specific audience. Sometimes, they try to represent material in a certain light for
rhetorical purpoases. They include books or articles about political
issues, historical events, scientific debates, or literary works.
Secondary sources can be reports, findings, or summaries of other researchers
on a topic, or they can be scholarly analysis of primary source material. |
| Tertiary
Sources |
Tertiary Sources provide information collected from primary
and secondary sources, and include
textbooks and almost all types of reference works, such as dictionaries,
encyclopedias, reviews, biographical sources, fact-books, and almanacs. |
|